A paper by Egilman, Bird, Mora and Druar puts into perspective some of the most salient barriers to progress in reducing HIV transmission, especially in countries where rates are highest. The very title of the paper alludes to the social and environmental 'determinants of health', something that the most discussed and best financed 'solutions' to the HIV pandemic generally ignore. As a result, global health aid can be rendered ineffective, even damaging, to healthcare in general and to narrower HIV prevention efforts.
The authors are particularly critical of disease-specific interventions or 'vertical approaches' to healthcare. Many of these, upon singling out a particular disease, such HIV, TB or malaria, proceed to expend copious quantities of money and other resources on these, to the exclusion of any attempt at addressing the reasons why these diseases are spreading.
The money is generally spent on drugs and other commodities, items that require people to be infected with the disease in question before being of any use. Anything that reduces the underlying health risks that people face, such as water, sanitation and hygiene, nutrition and food security, literacy, empowerment, poverty, etc, is ignored.
It's not a new discovery that drugs are a necessary, but by no means sufficient means of eradicating a disease. No disease has ever been eradicated by drugs alone and it seems unlikely that one ever will. Technical solutions, such as mass roll-out of drug therapies (antiretroviral treatment, Pre-exposure Prophylaxis, microbicides, male circumcision, vaccinations, and the like), are expensive. But if there is little or no health infrastructure, each vertical program needs to create its own infrastructure. This is inefficient and can contribute to what could be called the 'Bill Gates effect': everyone gets a pill but no one gets clean water with which to swallow it.
A far better way of characterizing health, which would have given rise to a more 'horizontal' approach, was that enshrined in the Alma Ata Declaration on Primary Health Care of 1978. This defines health as "a state of complete physical, mental and social wellbeing, and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity", involving "the action of many other social and economic sectors in addition to the health sector."
The date of the Alma Ata Declaration is particularly poignant because HIV, which had probably been spreading for decades, was only identified a few years later. Luckily, it was identified in a rich country, as it might have remained unnoticed for many more years if it had only infected people in developing countries.
Also poignant is the fact that the Declaration's definition of health was quite contrary to what became the dominant health paradigm, vertical programming. With vertical programming, disease is the measure of health; if you don't have a disease, you don't receive any of the benefits of health programs. Indeed, if you don't have the right disease, your health or lack of it is of no relevance.
The paper discusses the Gates Foundation approach to HIV and a handful of other headline grabbing diseases. This approach excludes any consideration of the conditions people live in, which allow these diseases to infect and affect so many. It also notes the shocking fact that two thirds of the Foundation's HIV/AIDS funding goes to vaccine research, which is labeled "preventative".
Even if a vaccine were developed and were made available to countries where HIV prevalence is highest, it is unlikely to prevent HIV transmission to any great extent. First, HIV prevention programs need to be able to identify who is most at risk of being infected. Currently, the majority of people infected in countries like Uganda, Kenya and Tanzania are those who would be thought least likely to be infected, those who don't engage in 'high risk' sexual behavior.
The paper discusses many vital issues in public health and development but I'll finish this posting with the authors' observation that "a usually unmeasured negative consequence of aid is the increase in nosocomial (hospital acquired) infections that can accompany immunization programs", and contaminated injections in general. In 2000, it was found that nearly 40% of injections were given with reused equipment and "caused an estimated 21 million HBV infections, two million HCV infections and 260,000 HIV infections, accounting for 32%, 40%, and 5% [of all transmission].”
Vertical programs generally don't measure such phenomena as infections, injuries and even deaths. The authors cite an apposite case of traditional birth attendants in Mexico being issued with one needle a month to administer depo provera, the hormonal contraceptive whose injectible version is common in African and some other developing countries, but strangely uncommon in wealthy countries.
HIV, like all diseases, is not independent of the conditions in which people live and spend much of their lives. That is precisely why health is "a state of complete physical, mental and social wellbeing, and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity".
How cruelly ironic it is that what could have been the most important and well timed decision about health ever made was replaced with a decision to view health as a commercial opportunity. As a result, big money only goes into that which allows the big players, the global pharmaceutical and healthcare industry, big philanthropy and NGOs, academia and international health institutions, to continue to grow and prosper.
Showing posts with label concurrency. Show all posts
Showing posts with label concurrency. Show all posts
Sunday, October 9, 2011
Thursday, October 6, 2011
HIV Testing: Health Services Lack Integrity, Not Legislation
Making HIV testing mandatory in all health facilities is said to be under consideration by Kenya's National Aids Control Program (NASCOP). Mandatory testing is not currently permitted under Kenyan law. However, people seem confused about what is currently permitted, some people thinking they have to comply with whatever a health facility worker requests and others thinking a test is mandatory under certain circumstances, such as pregnancy.
Mandatory testing is being mooted because voluntary testing has not allowed the country to reach its stated target of 80% of people knowing their status by 2013. But it seems unlikely that requiring people to take a HIV test before receiving treatment for various conditions other than HIV in health facilities will increase the numbers of people testing. It may even result in fewer people seeking health services, including HIV testing and counselling.
It will be very hard now to claw back years of ground lost by insisting that 80-90% of HIV is transmitted through heterosexual sex in African countries. But this is what will have to be done to reduce the stigma that still surrounds the virus. It is this very insistance about African sexual behavior that gives rise to the stigma.
Health providers may worry that people will lose confidence in them, and indeed they may. But continuing to lie about sexual transmission and refusing to investigate the relative contribution of non-sexual transmission to HIV epidemics will not help to solve the problem. If health services are to be trusted, they have to find a way to reverse the years of dishonesty. Making HIV testing mandatory, and especially arguing for it on the basis of the same old lies, will be counterproductive and dangerous.
Many of the problems that arise for large scale health programs, including the extremely well funded HIV related ones, stem from a lack of sustainability. Several countries have run out of drugs at various times. Most lack the capacity to monitor for drug resistance, loss to follow up and various other problems. If more people are tested under current conditions, sustainability will be further reduced.
Similarly heavy handed attitudes have resulted in wiespread confusion about the benefits of condoms and the possible side effects of hormonal contraception. Health services often seem to be unable to follow up on initiatives they start, for example, providing adequate counselling, treatment, care and even food and transport to health facilities for HIV positive people. Another dubious health issue is that of concurrency, which has been widely discredited, although it never had much empirical support.
Male circumcision rollout in Zambia appears to be a perfect example of why people may mistrust large health programs, especially ones relating to HIV and sexual health: "A large minority of participants (30% of adults and 45% of boys) gave incorrect answers to one question; they believed that getting circumcised was risk-free and did not have side-effects."
The best way to reduce stigma and allow people to feel less apprehensive about being tested for HIV is to come clean about the relative contributions of sexually and non-sexually transmitted HIV; we don't yet know the relative contributions. Investigating possible outbreaks of healthcare transmitted HIV would go a long way towards reducing people's fears, which may be quite legitimate.
Health and social services also need to be able to guarantee that people found to be HIV positive will receive the treatment, care and support they need, which can include protection from stigma and discrimination. And health facilities have to be able to provide services that don't themselves carry a higher risk of transmitting HIV than various kinds of sexual behavior. There's a long way to go to regain people's trust, but now is the best time to start if we want more people to be willing to find out their HIV status.
Labels:
aids,
blood donation,
concurrency,
cosmetic services,
hiv,
iatrogenic,
nosocomial,
prejudice,
risk,
stigma
Wednesday, October 5, 2011
HIV Not Very Like Syphilis; Surprised?
If 80 or 90% of HIV transmission is through heterosexual sex in African countries, as UNAIDS says, patterns of infection might be expected to resemble those found for syphilis, at least to some extent. But data collected several years ago in Kenya suggests that syphilis prevalence is relatively low and that there are many differences in patterns of infection.
HIV is more difficult to transmit through penile-vaginal sex, yet prevlance rates are much higher than those found for syphilis. But also, syphilis prevalence is similar among men and women. HIV prevalence is far higher among women than men in Kenya, overall, and more than five times higher in one large tribal group. Syphilis prevalence does not differ by urban/rural residence whereas HIV prevalence tends to cluster in urban areas. HIV prevalence in some rural areas is very low indeed.
While syphilis prevalence is highest among HIV positive men, HIV wasn't even found to be a significant risk factor for women. Syphilis prevalence tends to increase with age in men and women, whereas HIV prevalence tends to increase at a later age in men than in women, rising to higher prevalence rates among women than men, before dropping rapidly in older age groups among both men and women.
Syphilis prevalence is higher in Yaounde, Cameroon than it is in Kisumu, Kenya, although HIV prevalence in Yaounde is relatively low and in Kisumu it is very high. In South Africa, syphilis prevalence has declined far more rapidly than HIV in a similar period among antenatal clinic attendees.
Syphilis prevalence of over 10% has been recorded among Kenyan sex workers, among whom high STI rates could be expected. However, figures of 70-80% claimed for HIV prevalence among sex workers in the 1980s in Kenya and in the 1990s in Tanzania have never been recorded for syphilis, anywhere. In fact, in some countries HIV prevalence is not particularly high among sex workers unless they face additional risks, such as intravenous drug use.
Poorer men, and poorer women to a lesser extent, are more likely to have syphilis, as are men with lower levels of education. HIV prevalence tends to be higher among wealthier quintiles and among those who have higher levels of education, in Kenya, Tanzania and other countries.
It is worth bearing in mind that high prevalence of STIs does not mean that people necessarily engage in unusually high levels of unprotected sex. It does mean that health services, particularly sexual and reproductive health services, are inadequate.
I am concentrating on the differences between syphilis and HIV, but there are few remarkable similarities. I don't wish to deny that HIV is sometimes transmitted through heterosexual sex, just to question the extent of such transmission. Because, if transmission patterns are not very like those for syphilis, it would be a mistake to characterize HIV as an STI and design HIV prevention interventions accordingly.
Labels:
aids,
blood donation,
concurrency,
cosmetic services,
hiv,
iatrogenic,
nosocomial,
prejudice,
risk,
stigma
Sunday, October 2, 2011
Fruitful Discord At Lomborg's Copenhagen Consensus Center?
Up to now, UNAIDS' method of verifying their data has been the equivalent of printing out lots of copies of their reports and concluding that, because they all say the same thing, they must be true. First on the chopping block should be the HIV Modes of Transmission analyses (MoT), which purport to estimate the relative contribution of various routes of infection, sexual and non-sexual. In reality, the data used is a mishmash of guesswork and hot air.
The first paper to be published for RethinkHIV is by Lori Bollinger, who considers the cost effectiveness of non-sexual HIV transmission interventions. It's long and boring. But it's based on data such as that from MoT reports. Much though I'd like to criticize Bollinger's offering, I'll leave that to the authors of the second paper, Rob Baltussen and Jan Hontelez.
They are mercifully brief in their analysis, though they are far from merciful to Bollinger. They question if analyses such as Bollinger's can "really provide estimates that are sufficiently transparent, valid and reliable at the country level", and express serious doubts about the value of her work.
Baltussen and Hontelez don't feel that the models Bollinger uses "reflect the actual epidemiology" in the countries in question. Thankfully, they also doubt the adequacy of the "estimates of the relative contribution of each transmission route to the overall epidemic". In particular, they question the validity of the MoT reports used.
These researchers also examine the claimed impact of various HIV prevention interventions and remain unconvinced. They even have doubts about the costing data used for Bollinger's cost/benefit analysis. They point out that all these limitations are "inherent to the task at hand and therefore virtually inevitable". Baltussen and Hontelez do well to raise the issue of the usefulness of such data; yet much of UNAIDS' HIV policy is based on it.
The list of limitations goes on and on. While it is not one of the authors' conclusions, every criticism of Bollinger's offering is a criticism of UNAIDS, the HIV industry as a whole, and much of the HIV literature that has launched a thousand failed interventions per year for the last 20 years or so. The 'successes' among these interventions are based on grotesque overestimations that remain unquestioned even when program after program has failed to deliver the goods.
Despite unearthing all these limitations in the work of Bollinger, and much of the work of the HIV orthodoxy, the authors agree with Bollinger's conclusion: "that interventions to reduce non-sexual transmission of HIV are generally economically attractive". Which is great, as long as the "absence of comprehensive data" that Baltussen and Honetlez note is also rectified.
I'm still mystified as to the lack of consensus between the first and second paper commissioned by Lomborg and his gang. However, I'm not complaining. It makes a pleasant change to see researchers challenging each other rather than patting each other on the back. A few more papers like this and UNAIDS may even have to revise their lynchpin: the assumption that most HIV transmission in African countries is through heterosexual sex.
At less than five pages, Baltussen and Honetlez's paper is highly significant. But what influence will RethinkHIV have on the HIV orthodoxy? UNAIDS has discredited and branded anyone who has dared to challenge their racist, sexist and highly destructive stance. Will they do the same to these authors, or even to RethinkHIV? Perhaps Lomborg has miscalculated his credibility; HIV celebs gain their strength by supporting the orthodoxy, not by challenging it.
Incidentally, Lori Bollinger says elsewhere in a throwaway remark "the work we do is not about numbers and equations, but about people." But it is about numbers and equations and it is not about people. When Africans are asked about their sexual behavior, their answers show that they are human beings. They have similar sexual behaviors to other human beings. But researchers conclude that Africans 'underestimate' and/or 'overestimate' in their answers, effectively calling them all liars. (Thank you to Dr David Gisselquist for the Bollinger citation.)
Researchers tend to assume as a starting point that African sexual behavior (yes, apparently Africans are all the same) explains extremely high prevalence of a virus that is difficult to transmit sexually. Without this assumption their research is unlikely to be funded or published. But this has resulted in the current impasse in HIV prevention. The way forward is to investigate non-sexual HIV transmission but to use empirical data, not the stuff UNAIDS calls data.
[For more about non-sexual HIV transmission modes, such as unsafe health care and cosmetic services, visit the Don't Get Stuck With HIV website]
Labels:
aids,
blood donation,
concurrency,
cosmetic services,
hiv,
iatrogenic,
nosocomial,
prejudice,
risk,
stigma
Thursday, September 29, 2011
HIV Concurrency Theory is Dead; Can't You Smell it Yet?
In their desperation to explain why HIV prevalence is extremely high in African countries, hundreds of times higher than it is in many other countries, UNAIDS have flailed around and grabbed at any new theory that came their way. One of those theories was that overlapping sexual partnerships are responsible for levels of transmission that cannot be explained by any scientific data that is currently available. This is called the 'concurrency' hypothesis.
There remained the problem of showing that concurrency was exceptionally high in areas where HIV prevalence was high. This is still a problem and strong correlations between concurrency and HIV prevalence, even weak ones, have yet to be identified. But a more acute problem was the question of whether high rates of concurrency really would result in high rates of HIV transmission; is concurrency "especially effective in spreading HIV". The answer is 'no'.
Larry Sawers, Alan Isaac and Eileen Stillwaggon used a modified version of the mathematical model and data used by earlier researchers and added in an element that was missing from earlier work; 'coital dilution'. If someone has many partners, they have less sex per partner, on average. They found that, even with very high levels of concurrency, higher than those found in any population, once you add in slightly lower levels of coital frequency, the result is 'epidemic extinction'.
The orthodox view that Africans have inordinate amounts of sex, and inordinate amounts are required to explain massive HIV epidemics found in some African countries, is not supported by logical or empirical evidence. Only simulation models that use non-empirical evidence, or a very selective use of evidence, can 'explain' very high levels of heterosexual HIV transmission. And models that do use empirical evidence show that the orthodox view is wrong.
The authors conclude that "concurrency cannot be an important driver of HIV epidemics in subSaharan Africa. Alternative explanations for HIV epidemics in sub-Saharan Africa are needed." The concept of coital dilution even explains why "polygyny appears to protect populations from HIV", though UNAIDS often cite polygyny as a risk factor in the spread of HIV (note, this is not an argument for the promotion of polygyny, just one showing that it does not contribute significantly to HIV epidemics in Africa).
Indeed, other phenomena cited as factors that increase the spread of HIV are also put into perspective in this paper. Mobile populations, migrants, especially internal and temporary migrants have often been targeted by HIV campaigns. High rates of HIV in, for example, mining populations, were said to be a result of the sexual behavior of those infected. In the light of this research, miners are more likely to have been infected through shoddy health care practices provided by mine owners, who tend to score very badly in the field of corporate social responsibility.
The graphic depictions of epidemics driven by heterosexual sex alone becoming extinct are fascinating and I recommend the article. But there are other questions that were in need of answering before these researchers did this piece of work: why does the orthodox view of HIV, promulgated by UNAIDS and most of the other wealthy HIV institutions, fly in the face of evidence? And how can a view that is so inherently racist be accepted by so many?
But there's no point in wringing our hands in despair now that we know we have spent such a long time and so much money barking up the wrong tree. What are the 'alternative explanations' that these researchers suggest are needed? Eileen Stillwaggon herself has a whole set of suggestions, after all, why should there only be one way to reduce HIV transmission?
Plenty of other suggestions can be found on the Don't Get Stuck With HIV website, which looks at medical and cosmetic risks for HIV transmission. But at least we don't have to subscribe to the orthodox view of Africans as mere victims of their own stupidity, unsafe sexual behavior and lack of consideration for those around them, including their closest friends and relations.
Labels:
aids,
blood donation,
concurrency,
cosmetic services,
hiv,
iatrogenic,
nosocomial,
prejudice,
risk,
stigma
Sunday, July 24, 2011
Data Trumped by Idle Speculation and Pig-Headedness, as Usual
For many years, UNAIDS and the rest of the HIV industry have been sending out the message that everyone is at risk of being infected with HIV. However, it has never been true that everyone is at risk and there was never any reason for claiming this. The fact that HIV tended to cluster in urban areas, among wealthier, more mobile and better educated populations has been clear for a long time.
One of the latest papers to include detailed spacial data which demonstrates this clustering effect is entitled 'Localized spatial clustering of HIV infections in a widely disseminated rural South African epidemic', by Frank Tanser and colleagues. The data they produce is very interesting, but the same can certainly not be said of the conclusions they draw.
Unsurprisingly, they assume throughout that HIV is almost always transmitted through heterosexual sex in African countries, the so called 'behavioral paradigm'. And the study is in South Africa, the country with the largest number of people living with HIV in the world. As usual, the assumption is unexamined and unsupported in any way.
The study finds that high HIV prevalence clusters close to the National Road and that it is far lower in inaccessible rural areas. 40% of infected people live within 1km of the National Road. Also the "estimated density of HIV-infected individuals (total HIV cases per square kilometre) living within 1km of the road is 15.7 times higher than the mean density of infected individuals across the remainder of the study area."
Those infected are also better educated, wealthier and far more likely to be employed. No surprises there. And they are also less likely to be migrants. Migrants, especially internal migrants, are one of the groups often said to be at high risk of being infected and of infecting others. But the HIV industry has always been bad at identifying risk groups or, I should say, good at ignoring any evidence that may help identify them.
Whatever theories the paper's authors may have, indeed, whatever prejudices, all this data supports the view that HIV is not entirely spread sexually. The populations in this and other studies also have something else in common: they all live close to or have easy access to health facilities. Wealthy, well educated, mobile people with jobs tend to go to health facilities.
On the other hand, rural people tend to go to health facilities far less often, for various reasons, including poverty, lack of mobility, lack of health related education and the sheer lack of decent, affordable, accessible health facilities. Do these features of serious underdevelopment give people protection from HIV infection? Well, that's a hard question to answer if researchers like Tanser and colleagues don't even raise it.
The authors speculate about why the factors that may have been significant in HIV transmission during an early phase of the epidemic appear to be significant still and why this apparently heterosexually transmitted virus has not been more evenly spread among the population. Just how many warning signs do they need that their overall hypothesis about the virus being spread almost entirely through heterosexual sex is wrong and is little more than an anti-African prejudice?
As if things are not bad enough, this sort of idle speculation and pig-headed refusal to consider some fairly obvious alternatives to the behavioral paradigm is going to encourage those baying for 'treatment as prevention' and pre-exposure prophylaxis (essentially, means of substantially increasing the tonnage of drugs being thrown at the epidemic) to be rolled out in high prevalence countries.
One of the latest papers to include detailed spacial data which demonstrates this clustering effect is entitled 'Localized spatial clustering of HIV infections in a widely disseminated rural South African epidemic', by Frank Tanser and colleagues. The data they produce is very interesting, but the same can certainly not be said of the conclusions they draw.
Unsurprisingly, they assume throughout that HIV is almost always transmitted through heterosexual sex in African countries, the so called 'behavioral paradigm'. And the study is in South Africa, the country with the largest number of people living with HIV in the world. As usual, the assumption is unexamined and unsupported in any way.
The study finds that high HIV prevalence clusters close to the National Road and that it is far lower in inaccessible rural areas. 40% of infected people live within 1km of the National Road. Also the "estimated density of HIV-infected individuals (total HIV cases per square kilometre) living within 1km of the road is 15.7 times higher than the mean density of infected individuals across the remainder of the study area."
Those infected are also better educated, wealthier and far more likely to be employed. No surprises there. And they are also less likely to be migrants. Migrants, especially internal migrants, are one of the groups often said to be at high risk of being infected and of infecting others. But the HIV industry has always been bad at identifying risk groups or, I should say, good at ignoring any evidence that may help identify them.
Whatever theories the paper's authors may have, indeed, whatever prejudices, all this data supports the view that HIV is not entirely spread sexually. The populations in this and other studies also have something else in common: they all live close to or have easy access to health facilities. Wealthy, well educated, mobile people with jobs tend to go to health facilities.
On the other hand, rural people tend to go to health facilities far less often, for various reasons, including poverty, lack of mobility, lack of health related education and the sheer lack of decent, affordable, accessible health facilities. Do these features of serious underdevelopment give people protection from HIV infection? Well, that's a hard question to answer if researchers like Tanser and colleagues don't even raise it.
The authors speculate about why the factors that may have been significant in HIV transmission during an early phase of the epidemic appear to be significant still and why this apparently heterosexually transmitted virus has not been more evenly spread among the population. Just how many warning signs do they need that their overall hypothesis about the virus being spread almost entirely through heterosexual sex is wrong and is little more than an anti-African prejudice?
As if things are not bad enough, this sort of idle speculation and pig-headed refusal to consider some fairly obvious alternatives to the behavioral paradigm is going to encourage those baying for 'treatment as prevention' and pre-exposure prophylaxis (essentially, means of substantially increasing the tonnage of drugs being thrown at the epidemic) to be rolled out in high prevalence countries.
Monday, July 18, 2011
The Sound of a One Legged Argument Kicking Itself
As I mentioned in yesterday's blog, a recent article finds evidence for the concurrency hypothesis 'compelling', despite liberal use of words that suggests a lot of doubt. The hypothesis is that lots of unsafe sex alone, involving numerous partners, low condom use, etc, does not account for high HIV prevalence; but if sexual relationships overlap with each other, HIV transmission will be very high.
A lot of work has been done to show that the concurrency hypothesis is entirely unsupported by evidence, particularly work by Eileen Stillwaggon and Larry Sawers. But in the article mentioned yesterday, Mah and Shelton dismiss anything challenging the hypothesis rather than addressing the failure of all the arguments that claim to support it.
Well, an article just published by Frank Tanser and colleagues finds that there is "no evidence to suggest that concurrent partnerships are an important driver of HIV incidence in [a] typical high-prevalence rural African population." But instead they argue that multiple partnerships are an important driver of incidence.
While Mah and Shelton denied that non-sexually transmitted HIV plays an important role in hyperendemic scenarios, without arguing the case, Tanser and colleagues don't even mention the possibility of non-sexual transmission. While obligingly neutralizing an argument that should never have been given much credence, and one that has been convincingly refuted by others, they seem to be taking a step backwards.
We have been hearing the oversexed African hypothesis for several decades now, it even predates the identification of HIV. So all Tanser has done is revived that tired old reflex as an explanation of massive rates of HIV transmission. But what is it about Africans that results in a virus that is difficult to transmit sexually spreading so fast in a population in which sexual behavior is little different from that found in many other low HIV prevalence populations?
Rates of new infections per year for both males and females in the study population are shockingly high But the researchers don't appear to have established how HIV was being transmitted. They have just assumed that transmission is all through heterosexual sex and then attempted to work out how risky heterosexual sex is among participants. But why is heterosexual sex so risky there? We are not told.
The authors find that "More than 24% of the adult population are infected with HIV and infection peaks at more than 50% in women aged 25–29 years and 44% in men aged 30–34 years." Given the fairly low probability of sexual transmission of HIV, 80 or 90% of women must be exposed to HIV if such high percentages end up infected.
The fact that male prevalence peaks in an older age group than female prevalence is sometimes explained by the 'fact' that older men have younger partners. But only some men have younger partners. Some have partners the same age as themselves. Like a lot of HIV related data, you could be forgiven for thinking that HIV in males is a different virus from HIV in females.
Despite flogging the dead horse of concurrency, which is worthwhile when you consider how much credence it still seems to have in the HIV industry, the authors remark that concurrency may have played a big part in earlier stages in high prevalence epidemics. But earlier treatment of the concurrency hypothesis suggest otherwise, so this concession doesn't exactly strengthen their argument for a return to the promiscuity theory of HIV.
And when it comes to their recommendations for HIV prevention strategy they really seem to weaken. They argue that 'messages' shouldn't be 'diluted'. Pumping out a fairly undiluted though highly stigmatizing message about HIV for many years has not resulted in UNAIDS having much success in reducing transmission, despite spending billions. In fact, the pharmaceutical lobby trying to increase drug use in the pretence that it will reduce transmission even refers to the institution's prevention work as a failure.
Telling people the truth about HIV transmission is not 'diluting' anything. If people are at risk they need to know about the risks and how to avoid them. UNAIDS have used the issue of 'dilution' as a reason for denying non-sexual risks, with the result that most people don't know that such risks exist, and therefore cannot avoid them. HIV prevention is not just an advertising campaign, even if it's never looked much different from one.
A lot of work has been done to show that the concurrency hypothesis is entirely unsupported by evidence, particularly work by Eileen Stillwaggon and Larry Sawers. But in the article mentioned yesterday, Mah and Shelton dismiss anything challenging the hypothesis rather than addressing the failure of all the arguments that claim to support it.
Well, an article just published by Frank Tanser and colleagues finds that there is "no evidence to suggest that concurrent partnerships are an important driver of HIV incidence in [a] typical high-prevalence rural African population." But instead they argue that multiple partnerships are an important driver of incidence.
While Mah and Shelton denied that non-sexually transmitted HIV plays an important role in hyperendemic scenarios, without arguing the case, Tanser and colleagues don't even mention the possibility of non-sexual transmission. While obligingly neutralizing an argument that should never have been given much credence, and one that has been convincingly refuted by others, they seem to be taking a step backwards.
We have been hearing the oversexed African hypothesis for several decades now, it even predates the identification of HIV. So all Tanser has done is revived that tired old reflex as an explanation of massive rates of HIV transmission. But what is it about Africans that results in a virus that is difficult to transmit sexually spreading so fast in a population in which sexual behavior is little different from that found in many other low HIV prevalence populations?
Rates of new infections per year for both males and females in the study population are shockingly high But the researchers don't appear to have established how HIV was being transmitted. They have just assumed that transmission is all through heterosexual sex and then attempted to work out how risky heterosexual sex is among participants. But why is heterosexual sex so risky there? We are not told.
The authors find that "More than 24% of the adult population are infected with HIV and infection peaks at more than 50% in women aged 25–29 years and 44% in men aged 30–34 years." Given the fairly low probability of sexual transmission of HIV, 80 or 90% of women must be exposed to HIV if such high percentages end up infected.
The fact that male prevalence peaks in an older age group than female prevalence is sometimes explained by the 'fact' that older men have younger partners. But only some men have younger partners. Some have partners the same age as themselves. Like a lot of HIV related data, you could be forgiven for thinking that HIV in males is a different virus from HIV in females.
Despite flogging the dead horse of concurrency, which is worthwhile when you consider how much credence it still seems to have in the HIV industry, the authors remark that concurrency may have played a big part in earlier stages in high prevalence epidemics. But earlier treatment of the concurrency hypothesis suggest otherwise, so this concession doesn't exactly strengthen their argument for a return to the promiscuity theory of HIV.
And when it comes to their recommendations for HIV prevention strategy they really seem to weaken. They argue that 'messages' shouldn't be 'diluted'. Pumping out a fairly undiluted though highly stigmatizing message about HIV for many years has not resulted in UNAIDS having much success in reducing transmission, despite spending billions. In fact, the pharmaceutical lobby trying to increase drug use in the pretence that it will reduce transmission even refers to the institution's prevention work as a failure.
Telling people the truth about HIV transmission is not 'diluting' anything. If people are at risk they need to know about the risks and how to avoid them. UNAIDS have used the issue of 'dilution' as a reason for denying non-sexual risks, with the result that most people don't know that such risks exist, and therefore cannot avoid them. HIV prevention is not just an advertising campaign, even if it's never looked much different from one.
Sunday, July 17, 2011
Concurrency Regurgitated: Dubious Evidence Found Increasingly Credible by Experts
For unbridled spite and anti-African prejudice, packed up in some academic sounding writing, it would be hard to beat Timothy Mah and James Shelton's 'Concurrency revisited: increasing and compelling epidemiological evidence'. Don't worry, it's not in the least bit compelling.
One of the main claims of the article is that the person engaging in concurrent relationships doesn't face as high a risk as all their partners. And this is supposed to explain why another study showed that, although men were five times more likely to report having concurrent relationships than women, women are far more likely to be HIV positive.
The gist of the pro-concurrency argument is that while multiple partnerships alone, even the sort of multiples estimated by those with similar prejudices to Mah and Shelton, do not explain extraordinarily high rates of transmission found in many epidemics, concurrency does explain them.
Concurrency is roughly defined as "overlapping sexual partnerships in which sexual intercourse with one partner occurs between two acts of intercourse with another partner". But because there is little useful evidence about rates of such behavior, in African countries or anywhere else, researchers usually resort to data which bears little application to that (or any other) definition of the word.
Authors promoting the concept as an explanation of high HIV prevalence claim that it is the only possible explanation. However it is not an explanation at all, even if you insist, as the HIV industry does, that HIV is almost always transmitted through heterosexual sex in African countries. It has never been demonstrated that concurrency levels are high where HIV transmission is high or that high levels of concurrency even result in high rates of transmission.
Mah and Shelton proceed to list various pieces of research that show that HIV is probably frequently transmitted non sexually; they just don't see the research as showing this. Earlier researchers 'presumed' that HIV transmission where only one partner in a relationship is infected occurred through extra-marital sex. They generally didn't check and when they did, they chose not to believe anything that didn't fit their prejudices.
People like Mah and Shelton could do with a bit of instruction in basic logic. If you assume the truth of your conclusion and use that as your premise, you will end up with a fallacy. Some of the researchers are even frank enough to use words like 'presume' and 'probably' in their cited remarks. But Mah and Shelton feign complete confidence in their conclusions, despite the high incidence of words like 'appear', 'suggest', 'likely', 'may', etc, throughout their paper.
A recent paper which shows prominent clusters of HIV prevalence around roads does not, as Mah and Shelton wish to suggest, support the concurrency hypothesis. But it is consistent with the hypothesis that infections cluster around health facilities and routes to and from health facilities. However, even after exposure to the many articles they cite in their bibliography, they still adhere to their half baked ideas, finding them "reasonable and salient".
Given their insistence that HIV is almost always transmitted through heterosexual sex in high prevalence countries (though nowhere else), the authors plump for male circumcision as the reason why HIV transmission rates in West Africa have always been far lower than in East and South African countries. This especially weak version of the highly questionable mass male circumcision drive taking place in East and South Africa is said to be 'plausible', which probably shows more about the minds (and scruples) of the proponents than anything else.
Just when you might have thought those tired old arguments had been put out to grass, along come Mah and Shelton to compound them with some even more clapped out considerations. In my next post I'll cover an article which shows that concurrency is not a significant driver of HIV transmission but that multiple partnerships are. And that old chestnut dates back to the days when even experts agreed that HIV wasn't always sexually transmitted. But that's how AIDS billions get spent.
One of the main claims of the article is that the person engaging in concurrent relationships doesn't face as high a risk as all their partners. And this is supposed to explain why another study showed that, although men were five times more likely to report having concurrent relationships than women, women are far more likely to be HIV positive.
The gist of the pro-concurrency argument is that while multiple partnerships alone, even the sort of multiples estimated by those with similar prejudices to Mah and Shelton, do not explain extraordinarily high rates of transmission found in many epidemics, concurrency does explain them.
Concurrency is roughly defined as "overlapping sexual partnerships in which sexual intercourse with one partner occurs between two acts of intercourse with another partner". But because there is little useful evidence about rates of such behavior, in African countries or anywhere else, researchers usually resort to data which bears little application to that (or any other) definition of the word.
Authors promoting the concept as an explanation of high HIV prevalence claim that it is the only possible explanation. However it is not an explanation at all, even if you insist, as the HIV industry does, that HIV is almost always transmitted through heterosexual sex in African countries. It has never been demonstrated that concurrency levels are high where HIV transmission is high or that high levels of concurrency even result in high rates of transmission.
Mah and Shelton proceed to list various pieces of research that show that HIV is probably frequently transmitted non sexually; they just don't see the research as showing this. Earlier researchers 'presumed' that HIV transmission where only one partner in a relationship is infected occurred through extra-marital sex. They generally didn't check and when they did, they chose not to believe anything that didn't fit their prejudices.
People like Mah and Shelton could do with a bit of instruction in basic logic. If you assume the truth of your conclusion and use that as your premise, you will end up with a fallacy. Some of the researchers are even frank enough to use words like 'presume' and 'probably' in their cited remarks. But Mah and Shelton feign complete confidence in their conclusions, despite the high incidence of words like 'appear', 'suggest', 'likely', 'may', etc, throughout their paper.
A recent paper which shows prominent clusters of HIV prevalence around roads does not, as Mah and Shelton wish to suggest, support the concurrency hypothesis. But it is consistent with the hypothesis that infections cluster around health facilities and routes to and from health facilities. However, even after exposure to the many articles they cite in their bibliography, they still adhere to their half baked ideas, finding them "reasonable and salient".
Given their insistence that HIV is almost always transmitted through heterosexual sex in high prevalence countries (though nowhere else), the authors plump for male circumcision as the reason why HIV transmission rates in West Africa have always been far lower than in East and South African countries. This especially weak version of the highly questionable mass male circumcision drive taking place in East and South Africa is said to be 'plausible', which probably shows more about the minds (and scruples) of the proponents than anything else.
Just when you might have thought those tired old arguments had been put out to grass, along come Mah and Shelton to compound them with some even more clapped out considerations. In my next post I'll cover an article which shows that concurrency is not a significant driver of HIV transmission but that multiple partnerships are. And that old chestnut dates back to the days when even experts agreed that HIV wasn't always sexually transmitted. But that's how AIDS billions get spent.
Monday, February 7, 2011
Global HIV Policy: Blame, Stigma and Finger-Wagging
With HIV/AIDS, it's always been easier to blame individuals for their reckless behavior than to examine the conditions people live in and figure out which of these conditions may explain why HIV prevalence varies from a fraction of a percent in some populations to 25% in others and even 40% in some demographic groups.
The idea that whole populations have hundreds of times less sexual experience than other groups is not credible, especially where birth rates may be very high in some countries with low HIV prevalence. India is an example of a country with high birth rates and HIV prevalence lower than 1%. There is no reason to think that Indians in general shy away from sex.
While prevalence is a lot lower than 1% in most demographic groups in India, it is 30-40% in some demographic groups in several African countries. In fact, prevalence among Indian sex workers is only 7%, which is about the same prevalence as found in Kenya, Tanzania and Uganda. Yet sex workers in India face terrible risks, far worse than most sexually active people in African countries.
That HIV prevalence is not correlated with individual sexual behavior is nothing new. But some researchers have shown that HIV prevalence is correlated with malaria prevalence, something that is clearly not just a matter of individual behavior. Whether it makes HIV positive people more likely to transmit the virus, HIV negative people more likely to be infected or both is not clear. I have only seen the abstract. But it is one more nail in the coffin for the 'individual responsibility' theory of HIV prevention.
People in high malaria prevalence areas are more than twice as likely to be HIV positive as those in low prevalence areas. Some people have been calling for research into cofactors in HIV transmission for years but such research is still relatively uncommon. But similar research was recently carried out on schistosomiasis (bilharzia) as a co-factor and it was found to be associated with higher HIV prevalence. Tuberculosis also makes people more likely to transmit and to be infected with HIV.
Further loosening the connection between HIV and individual sexual behavior, it has also been shown that "a number of biological factors are critical in determining whether an unprotected sexual exposure to HIV results in productive infection". Mentioned are "viral factors, host genetics, and the impact of co-infections and host immunology" but again, I only have access to the abstract.
These researchers even have the effrontery to claim that "HIV sexual transmission is very inefficient". That's true, but it's not something that the sex obsessed HIV industry likes to dwell on. Global HIV prevention policies are based on blame, stigma, finger-pointing and finger-wagging, not research. But these upstarts go on to mention destigmatizing the issue, leading to new and more effective strategies for prevention. Whatever next?
Another batch of researchers conclude that because new HIV infections among discordant couples (where only one partner is infected) are twice as likely to occur among those trying to have a baby, this must be a result of higher levels of 'risky' sexual behavior. Having sex with your partner is not risky, or shouldn't be. But having a baby seems to be, especially for the female partner. Perhaps the researchers would like to assess the non-sexual risks that pregnant women face, such as unsafe health care.
The researchers may well be right and their research is certainly very interesting. But any research into HIV transmission among discordant couples, especially where pregnancy is involved, is incomplete without some clarification about how the women are being infected. Sure, they must be having sex if they are trying to have children, but this does not mean that transmission is always sexual.
The 'concurrency' card is still frequently played by those in the know (about how to receive copious amounts of funding) but it is still unsupported by clear evidence that it is common or that it really does explain high rates of HIV transmission. This research from Kenya pours cold water on the concurrency theory, finding that only 3.5% of females and 4% of males were engaged in concurrent partnerships in the previous six months.
The authors claim their findings suggest that: "concurrency expands individuals' sexual networks and bridges additional networks involving partners' other sexual partners". Perhaps, but with such low rates of concurrence, it's unlikely to do so to any great extent.
We need credible explanations for high rates of HIV transmission and viable prevention interventions, not the institutional racism and sexism that we have come to expect from UNAIDS and their ilk. UNAIDS have spent long enough showing that they are not capable of acting on research, especially research that exposes their prejudice for what it is. It's time for them to stand aside and let an unbiased institution take over.
The idea that whole populations have hundreds of times less sexual experience than other groups is not credible, especially where birth rates may be very high in some countries with low HIV prevalence. India is an example of a country with high birth rates and HIV prevalence lower than 1%. There is no reason to think that Indians in general shy away from sex.
While prevalence is a lot lower than 1% in most demographic groups in India, it is 30-40% in some demographic groups in several African countries. In fact, prevalence among Indian sex workers is only 7%, which is about the same prevalence as found in Kenya, Tanzania and Uganda. Yet sex workers in India face terrible risks, far worse than most sexually active people in African countries.
That HIV prevalence is not correlated with individual sexual behavior is nothing new. But some researchers have shown that HIV prevalence is correlated with malaria prevalence, something that is clearly not just a matter of individual behavior. Whether it makes HIV positive people more likely to transmit the virus, HIV negative people more likely to be infected or both is not clear. I have only seen the abstract. But it is one more nail in the coffin for the 'individual responsibility' theory of HIV prevention.
People in high malaria prevalence areas are more than twice as likely to be HIV positive as those in low prevalence areas. Some people have been calling for research into cofactors in HIV transmission for years but such research is still relatively uncommon. But similar research was recently carried out on schistosomiasis (bilharzia) as a co-factor and it was found to be associated with higher HIV prevalence. Tuberculosis also makes people more likely to transmit and to be infected with HIV.
Further loosening the connection between HIV and individual sexual behavior, it has also been shown that "a number of biological factors are critical in determining whether an unprotected sexual exposure to HIV results in productive infection". Mentioned are "viral factors, host genetics, and the impact of co-infections and host immunology" but again, I only have access to the abstract.
These researchers even have the effrontery to claim that "HIV sexual transmission is very inefficient". That's true, but it's not something that the sex obsessed HIV industry likes to dwell on. Global HIV prevention policies are based on blame, stigma, finger-pointing and finger-wagging, not research. But these upstarts go on to mention destigmatizing the issue, leading to new and more effective strategies for prevention. Whatever next?
Another batch of researchers conclude that because new HIV infections among discordant couples (where only one partner is infected) are twice as likely to occur among those trying to have a baby, this must be a result of higher levels of 'risky' sexual behavior. Having sex with your partner is not risky, or shouldn't be. But having a baby seems to be, especially for the female partner. Perhaps the researchers would like to assess the non-sexual risks that pregnant women face, such as unsafe health care.
The researchers may well be right and their research is certainly very interesting. But any research into HIV transmission among discordant couples, especially where pregnancy is involved, is incomplete without some clarification about how the women are being infected. Sure, they must be having sex if they are trying to have children, but this does not mean that transmission is always sexual.
The 'concurrency' card is still frequently played by those in the know (about how to receive copious amounts of funding) but it is still unsupported by clear evidence that it is common or that it really does explain high rates of HIV transmission. This research from Kenya pours cold water on the concurrency theory, finding that only 3.5% of females and 4% of males were engaged in concurrent partnerships in the previous six months.
The authors claim their findings suggest that: "concurrency expands individuals' sexual networks and bridges additional networks involving partners' other sexual partners". Perhaps, but with such low rates of concurrence, it's unlikely to do so to any great extent.
We need credible explanations for high rates of HIV transmission and viable prevention interventions, not the institutional racism and sexism that we have come to expect from UNAIDS and their ilk. UNAIDS have spent long enough showing that they are not capable of acting on research, especially research that exposes their prejudice for what it is. It's time for them to stand aside and let an unbiased institution take over.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

